I Will Review Your Channel

S

Science Saturdays

Liking YTtalk
I AM CURRENTLY NOT TAKING NEW SUBMISSIONS. CHECK BACK AT A LATER TIME.

I saw another thread similar to this one and I figured I would help others that need/want it.

Qualifications (Must meet these to be reviewed)
  • Less than 100 subs (I figure if you have more you know what you are doing)
  • More than 5 videos
What You Get
  • I will review your channel art and channel trailer
  • I will review 1 video of your choice-please say which one in your post
So if you want a review and meet the qualifications go ahead and post!

P.S. Donations are appreciated! ;) (Via the bank feature)
 
Last edited:
I feel like I would rather get my channel reviewed by someone who has more views and subs.
 
Science Saturdays said:
I saw another thread similar to this one and I figured I would help others that need/want it.

Qualifications (Must meet these to be reviewed)
  • Less than 100 subs (I figure if you have more you know what you are doing)
  • More than 5 videos
What You Get
  • I will review your channel art and channel trailer
  • I will review 1 video of your choice-please say which one in your post
So if you want a review and meet the qualifications go ahead and post!

P.S. Donations are appreciated! ;) (Via the bank feature)
Click to expand...
Darn, I just got over 100 subscribers a few weeks ago :(

Well, it isn't like I had any YTtalk cash I could donate to you anyway...
 
Alrod360 said:
I feel like I would rather get my channel reviewed by someone who has more views and subs.
Click to expand...
Fair Enough.
Fibula said:
Can you please review my channel? The video I want reviewed is called stolen water Lilys :)
Click to expand...
Channel Art
The channel art looks really good! Same thing with the logo. The one thing I would improve on here is maybe shifting over the word "new." It sort of blends in with the stain on the paper.
Video
The video was ok. The one thing I heard was a consistent buzz throughout the video. I suggest getting a better mic or an audio cleaner program/software. Also, when you are editing your videos, go ahead and edit out the "arm stretch to the camera to press a button on the camera." When you finish talking, wait about 2 seconds and then turn off the camera. This should leave a wide enough gap to edit out that awkward arm stretch thing.
Thrashbat said:
Darn, I just got over 100 subscribers a few weeks ago :(

Well, it isn't like I had any YTtalk cash I could donate to you anyway...
Click to expand...

I'll do one for you ;)
Channel Art
The channel art I pretty basic but also seamless. The logo blends right in with the channel art, but you might want to reconsider what is on the logo. It doesn't really portray the channel in any way or give me an understanding of what "Tm" is.
Video
I watched the video titled Untitled For Now. I just have to say that it was hilarious. The animations were good (always room for improvement, but they are great for what you are doing), and I don't really have any negative feedback. Maybe add a watermark over you videos for added branding (via YouTube inVideo Programming).
 
Science Saturdays said:
Fair Enough.

Channel Art
The channel art looks really good! Same thing with the logo. The one thing I would improve on here is maybe shifting over the word "new." It sort of blends in with the stain on the paper.
Video
The video was ok. The one thing I heard was a consistent buzz throughout the video. I suggest getting a better mic or an audio cleaner program/software. Also, when you are editing your videos, go ahead and edit out the "arm stretch to the camera to press a button on the camera." When you finish talking, wait about 2 seconds and then turn off the camera. This should leave a wide enough gap to edit out that awkward arm stretch thing.


I'll do one for you ;)
Channel Art
The channel art I pretty basic but also seamless. The logo blends right in with the channel art, but you might want to reconsider what is on the logo. It doesn't really portray the channel in any way or give me an understanding of what "Tm" is.
Video
I watched the video titled Untitled For Now. I just have to say that it was hilarious. The animations were good (always room for improvement, but they are great for what you are doing), and I don't really have any negative feedback. Maybe add a watermark over you videos for added branding (via YouTube inVideo Programming).
Click to expand...
Thank you! Well, the guitar-brush is supposed to represent what we do (music and animation) and the Tm stands for Thrashimation, but okay. We're making new art for the banner anyway :)
As for the video, thank you! We're pretty proud of it :D
 
socialsketch said:
Citizen's Arrest Prank
Click to expand...
Channel Art
The channel art is fantastic and completely embodies what your channel is about. On the other hand, if I look at your logo while watching a video, its appears sort of small and I can't see you too well. My advice: Crop the pic and blow it up so it is just you and not so much surrounding space.
Video
The concept was great, and the first few times you pranked people were hilarious, but the video sort of dragged on near the end. Cut out the "ehh" reactions and only show the great ones! Keep them around the size of your other videos-around 2 minutes!
 
Hey can you check out our channel? We're pretty new so I know we have a to work on but we could definitely use the feedback, look at our short film called "Dead Zone" probably our best work.

Thanks!
 
Dark Tower Pictures said:
Hey can you check out our channel? We're pretty new so I know we have a to work on but we could definitely use the feedback, look at our short film called "Dead Zone" probably our best work.

Thanks!
Click to expand...
Channel Art
The logo is great-easy to recognize and remember. The channel art on the other hand is blurry (try getting a higher resolution picture) and doesn't really blend in with the rest of the channel. I would recommend matching it up with the logo.
Video
This may just be me going crazy, but I think I heard (around 3:25) a little sound maybe where the camera operator either hit the camera or something else. Like I said,
it is probably just be my imagination but try to not make any extraneous noises. The video was really amazing and I enjoyed it from beginning to end. Now, it was so good I have to go into really fine detail to give feedback and critique. In my opinion, the main character's clothes looked really good in shape for being in an apocalypse for so long. As the comment on the video said, the "twist" could of been explained in greater detail. But other that, the video was great! Just work on the fine details that really make a film believable.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top