Do you believe in the YouTube algorithm?

I've had videos place in the search next to videos with 100x the views of mine. I can't explain why I'm above someone with 250k views but I do believe that videos being watched will stay up there and ones not being watched won't. But a properly tagged video will appear somewhere and some people click on everything.
 
Sure do.

But then once in a while you see a video from 3 years ago that gets to the frontpage of youtube for who knows why. This is real btw, like 2 days ago I saw a video with no tags, a 3 minute video of about 50% retention suddenly getting like 300k views in 1 day from a channel that last uploaded 3 years ago. lol GG youtube~
 
What I do to combat the algorithm is not give a s**t about it because it's out of my control as far as I can see within reason.
 
I listened to Tim Schmoyer's podcast with Matt Geiler recently where they discussed the algorithm. I'm wondering if you guys believe it? I feel like I'm being affected by it. At least one part they discussed where poorly performing videos affect the ones that come after. It certainly makes sense that YouTube would do that, but it makes it hard to figure out what you can do to combat the negative effects that come from a poorly performing video or two.

What do you guys think?

I believe wholeheartedly. Think of it an an all-knowing, benevolent, yet stern, leader. It will reward you when you give it things it wants, and it will punish you when you don't ignoring your videos as you aim relentlessly to please it

The more I do this, the more I believe that you must actually satisfy the algorithm's demands, before you satisfy the viewer's expectations. Simply because if you don't make the algorithm happy, it won't show your videos to viewers.

I don't think 1 video would have a negative impact, but more than one certainly does. It's the reverse of building authority, if you start releasing videos that no one wants to see, you lose channel authority.

The secret to success (if there ever was a secret) is to build a base authority, then release a series of videos unique in some ways that generate huge views to build large subs, then continue to build authority. If you stop at that point, you will lose authority and drop down.

I believe currently one needs about 30-50 videos to build any sort of authority before the algorithm sends you traffic. Since things fall much faster than they rise, I would guess you would need 5-10 "bad" videos before you drop channel authority, and suffer the consequences of reduced placements and traffic.

Currently, views do seem down across the board, on our channel about 40% from a peak a few weeks ago. It is the back to school effect, and other kids channels are affected, so it's a case of a rising and falling tide carrying all ships.
 
Last edited:
Sure do.

But then once in a while you see a video from 3 years ago that gets to the frontpage of youtube for who knows why. This is real btw, like 2 days ago I saw a video with no tags, a 3 minute video of about 50% retention suddenly getting like 300k views in 1 day from a channel that last uploaded 3 years ago. lol GG youtube~
Not knowing the details it would be hard to say why it suddenly jumped up. My first thought would be that someone put it on a blog, reddit or whatever and started generating a lot of views. If youtube sees something is hot and being watched, why not promote it a bit further until it goes in the wrong direction again.

Another alternative would be that the algorithm randomly digs up old stuff which I find hard to believe, but hey, humans make mistakes so it could be a programmer error that happens once in a blue moon (bug).
 
Not knowing the details it would be hard to say why it suddenly jumped up. My first thought would be that someone put it on a blog, reddit or whatever and started generating a lot of views. If youtube sees something is hot and being watched, why not promote it a bit further until it goes in the wrong direction again.

Another alternative would be that the algorithm randomly digs up old stuff which I find hard to believe, but hey, humans make mistakes so it could be a programmer error that happens once in a blue moon (bug).

¯\_(ツ)_/¯
 
"The algorithm" is a bit misleading, I think. There are many facets to the search results that are being tweaked all the time by Google, which is why SEO is such a difficult thing to get right. If there were any one strategy that worked every single time, then it wouldn't be difficult to get top rated videos (or ads or articles), or else it'd just wash out in a glut of everyone doing exactly the same thing. So you can work towards the things that YouTube tells you to do, and you'll get rewarded for that. I think the best advice comes directly from YouTube, because they're the ones who want to show advertisers that certain content will lead to certain viewer profiles clicking on certain ads.

Our videos are incidental to YouTube. They're just the delivery system for their ads. So keeping that in mind, if you're looking for growth, can keep you sane when you feel you're being judged by the system.
 
"The algorithm" is a bit misleading, I think. There are many facets to the search results that are being tweaked all the time by Google, which is why SEO is such a difficult thing to get right. If there were any one strategy that worked every single time, then it wouldn't be difficult to get top rated videos (or ads or articles), or else it'd just wash out in a glut of everyone doing exactly the same thing. So you can work towards the things that YouTube tells you to do, and you'll get rewarded for that. I think the best advice comes directly from YouTube, because they're the ones who want to show advertisers that certain content will lead to certain viewer profiles clicking on certain ads.

Our videos are incidental to YouTube. They're just the delivery system for their ads. So keeping that in mind, if you're looking for growth, can keep you sane when you feel you're being judged by the system.
Thanks! The ship has sailed on keeping me sane.
 
Back
Top