Banner- Need Your Opinions :)

[Brodie]

So i'm working on my new banner and rebranding my channel to have a 'clean' look with a hint of sketchyness and I need your opinion on something, quite badly...
I know it's a simple thing but i'm a perfectionist and like things to be perfect, I can't decide if this clone picture should have a shadow or not. To tie in with the 3d text but also without it has that sketch feel.
without shadow with shadow
instead of any of these I thought maybe a suttle glow or just a soften edges might do, all opinions are greatly valued, thanks

 

[Caber]

I think it looks better with a shadow.

 

[Smexi]

Soften the edges!

 

[Brodie]

ok here's the final thing, feel free to put in any critiques

 

[Caber]

Sexy.

 

[Kath]

I would go with the shadow It's looking great though!!

 

[Brodie]

Sexy.

aha i'm sure it is

 

[Dustin Jolley]

ok here's the final thing, feel free to put in any critiques
View attachment 17335

Cool, bro. Excellent work, my young friend.[DOUBLEPOST=1394491751,1394491685][/DOUBLEPOST]

So i'm working on my new banner and rebranding my channel to have a 'clean' look with a hint of sketchyness and I need your opinion on something, quite badly...
I know it's a simple thing but i'm a perfectionist and like things to be perfect, I can't decide if this clone picture should have a shadow or not. To tie in with the 3d text but also without it has that sketch feel.
View attachment 17330 without shadowView attachment 17331 with shadow
instead of any of these I thought maybe a suttle glow or just a soften edges might do, all opinions are greatly valued, thanks

Cool, yo homie g dawg. You're very good at this sort of thing.

 

[Brodie]

Cool, bro. Excellent work, my young friend.[DOUBLEPOST=1394491751,1394491685][/DOUBLEPOST]

Cool, yo homie g dawg. You're very good at this sort of thing.

thanks

 

[Dustin Jolley]

thanks

Very welcome, bro. I hope you don't mind me calling you yo homie g dawg and stuff like that. Lol!